Search PalmPower's 487 Palm-related article archive 
Home
EasyPrint
News details Click here for the RSS feed's XML code. This is not a browser URL.
Articles-only Click here for the RSS feed's XML code. This is not a browser URL.
Comparing Windows CE with Palm OS (continued)

There's also the issue of multitasking to consider as well. While the real-time embedded AMX kernel that Palm Computing licensed from KADAK can multitask, the Palm OS itself does not have this capability. As stated in Palm's Developer FAQ:

Palm OS is built on top of a small kernel that Palm Computing licensed from Kadak. The terms and conditions of that license specifically state that Palm may not expose the API for creating/manipulating tasks within the OS. If you need access to these calls you need to contact Kadak at (604) 734-2796.

The Palm OS ROM is built with support for a very few tasks. There are only enough task slots for the ROM's needs. In order to support more tasks, the ROM would need to be rebuilt.

Windows CE, on the other hand, is designed to run multiple programs and tasks simultaneously. Whether or not this is useful on a Palm-sized device like the Nino is debatable, but certainly on larger form factor devices, where you might have a Web browser open in one window and a word processor open in another, it's a good thing, as Martha Stewart would say. Multitasking is also beneficial during synchronization (Windows CE devices synchronize all the time when plugged into their docking cradles). It's also a good fit for wireless applications, where email and web pages might be downloaded over the airwaves in the background when the user is doing something else, such as reading email or searching through a contacts database. Multitasking is important to wireless field data collection applications as well, where a handheld device could upload stored information to a remote database while the user is keying in information, such as for stock-keeping and medical diagnostics type programs. Because of its robustness in this area, Windows CE is the preferred platform for this type of application.

Let's not forget about multimedia either. Windows CE can produce color graphics in high resolutions, and some of the newer units, like Compaq's Aero, can play MPEG animations and digitized stereo music. By comparison, the Palm OS is lucky if it can display 2 shades of black-and-white and reproduce an audible beep on a tiny peizoelectic speaker.

The Palm organizer is the better organizer
All of this may sound like we're giving the Palm OS short shrift. In reality, as a personal organizer, Palm OS is the real winner here. Who has actually tried to use Pocket Outlook on a Palm-sized PC, with its array of buttons, controls and drop-down lists, in place of the simple built-in contact list? Or have actually tried to take notes with Note Taker? Those who have tried can probably tell you how difficult it really is, because the Windows interface doesn't translate well to small screens. With all of CE's API's, its monster memory pool, hardware expandability, color graphics, voice recognition and gee-whiz sound, it's the Palm OS's simplicity that makes it such a successful organizer.

What the future holds
It all has to do with trade-offs. Windows CE is certainly the more "real" operating system, but because it's so complicated, it trades off application performance and ease of use for rich API's, vast amounts of addressable memory, expandability and the ability to run on different hardware platforms. The little Palm OS is extremely optimized for running small, efficient personal productivity programs, but it has almost no expandability except through cleverly engineered software and hardware hacks, and the OS is too simplistic to handle running monolithic applications.


« Previous  ·  1  ·  2  ·  3  ·  4  ·  Next »
Other articles you might like
Home > Phones and PDAs > Palm and Treo (527 articles)
   How to start clean with a new Palm handheld
   Veo Photo Traveler puts a camera in your SD card slot
   Palm's strategic relationships aim to extend applications to wireless world
Home > Phones and PDAs > Windows Mobile (102 articles)
   Finding your way with the Pharos Pocket GPS Navigator
   Pocket PC Viruses: Myth or looming threat?
   Get organized with your Pocket PC
Home > Reviews > Software > Palm (195 articles)
   TealOS: great Palm software you are prohibited from buying
   CallRec gives your Treo better call recording
   Edit Office files on the go with Documents To Go
Home > Reviews > Software > Windows Mobile (38 articles)
   Best of the best in GPS apps
   Weathering the storm: forecasts on your Pocket PC
   Chow down and limber up with CalorieKing
Get Weekly Email Updates
Subscribe to our regular weekly email newsletter. It's packed with tips, reviews, deep analysis, and the latest news.
 
Other PalmPower Articles
Palm gets up to date with new Tungsten family of handhelds
Create handwritten email with riteMail
Presenter-to-Go puts PowerPoint presentations on your Palm OS handheld
Looking for the cutting edge
Gain remote access to databases and PLCs
PalmSource Open House showcases what's new in the Palm community
Analysis: handheld market share
More from the ZATZ journals
Computing Unplugged: The iPad: Apple's latest heartbreaker
David Gewirtz Online: CNN commentary and analysis
DominoPower: Lotusphere 2010: mobility and collaboration
OutlookPower: Running auto-respond rules when Outlook is closed
-- Advertisement --

SECURE YOUR SITE WITH AN IRONCLAD SSL CERTIFICATE
An IronClad SSL Certificate helps you build an impenetrable fortress around your customer's credit card information. IronClad SSL Certificates are:

  • Fully validated
  • Up to 256-bit encryption
  • Up to 10 years validity
  • Stringent authentication
  • Around-the-clock customer support

Build trust. Protect your customers. Grow your online business.

Tap here now and be IronClad with SSL tonight.

ZATZ Home  ·  News  ·  Back Issues  ·  Credits/Trademarks ·  Link To Us
Copyright © 1998-2010, ZATZ Publishing. All rights reserved worldwide.
Editor's Login